(Back to ARTICLES)
Forget the Myths Women Want Overseas Assignments
(this article first appeared in www.expatica.com/hr)
European women executives should be aware that women hold a very low percentage of all international management positions. This circumstance not only hinders the business success of their firms abroad but it also limits opportunities for women to succeed at home. Most multinational companies prefer that their senior management have abundant overseas experience. Excluded from that experience, women are also excluded from promotions and power later in their careers. Mary van der Boon investigates.
According to Queens University professor and gender management specialist Dr. Carol McKeen, international mobility of female professionals and managers across subsidiaries is often restricted because of women's (perceived or real) family attachment and the social norms which still regard men as the primary breadwinners. Spousal issues for female expatriates may also be more complex, as they are more likely to have employed spouses who will need support in relocating.
Barriers Come from Within
Contrary to popular corporate myth, female managers often report the biggest barriers coming from within the corporation, rather than from situations actually encountered during foreign assignments.
An Australian survey has concluded that women's accomplishments are attributed to luck and external factors, including affirmative action, whereas men's are attributed to skill and ability. The latter have higher worth in the labour market. In addition, theories of statistical discrimination hold that employers expect lower productivity returns for professional women than for equally-qualified men due to probability estimates of turnover, work commitment, and skills that encompass the population at large. This thinking can lead to job assignments for women that limit their skill and knowledge gains, including those across borders. "We talk about the fact that women have to be "overripe" for promotion - they have to demonstrate they can do the next job before they get promoted to it, while men are promoted much earlier when they're hungry, not when (they're) ready." says Jennifer Allyn of Catalyst, a New York search group.
Dr. Nancy Adler has identified three key barriers to selection of women on international assignments:
- the assumption that women simply do not want to be international managers because of work/family conflicts (particularly married women and working mothers)
- the outright refusal of some companies to send women abroad, owing to fears about their competence or their physical safety
- the belief that many foreigners are prejudiced against women expatriate managers
Where senior management assumes that married women do not want international careers, it is unlikely that these organisations will invest in the development of their women managers and provide assignments with power and opportunity. Research has indicated that because men hold most upper level management positions, they do most hiring, including sending individuals on overseas assignments, and they may not be willing to offer career advancement opportunities to women subordinates.
What can HR do?
Workforce magazine has described an unfortunate reality: even though women comprise half the workforce in most countries, men are still the overwhelming choice when it comes to selecting candidates for overseas assignments. When surveyed, respondents admitted that 71 percent of employees who are eligible for an expatriate assignment are male, and only one woman is offered an assignment for every 10 men offered. The discrimination persists despite the fact that women accept assignments at a greater rate than men do (90 percent of men versus 99 percent of women), and that they enjoy a higher assignment success rate.
Committed HR professionals know that developing a global database and posting all expatriate positions the company is seeking to fill on company intranets (open to all applicants) will address diversity and glass borders issues in international management by encouraging women, minority and differently abled candidates to apply.
Development of an expatriate competency profile linked to global and transnational strategy will also banish forever the spectre of patronage, cronyism, sexism and racism in expatriate selection and assessment procedures. Todays competitive global marketplace requires a working environment which visibly demonstrates a commitment to people, and enables these people to contribute to their full potential.
Helping those who help themselves
Women seeking international assignments might follow Harriet Rubins advice in her best-selling book for women leaders,The Princessa: Machiavelli for Women : "Women have avoided conflict for too long. They must wage war in their personal and professional lives to get what they want," maintains Rubin. Her advice to women everywhere? "Ask for everything. Women think their needs will be perceived, that they are obvious. Youll never know what you can get if you dont bother to ask."
International networks are essential to todays women abroad. The tendency of women who made it to the top to pull the ladder up behind them has been replaced by a new generation of women eager to share the secrets of their success. In the Netherlands organizations such as Womens International Networking (www.womensinternational.net) and Unie Vrouwelijke Ondernemers Nederland (Union of Women Entrepreneurs, www.uvon.nl) can help provide the necessary contacts.
Mary van der Boon is Managing Director of global tmc international, www.globaltmc.com
The Case for Women Expatriate Managers in Europe
In a recent study of European Female Expatriate Careers, authors Dr. Margaret Linehan (Cork Institute of Technology) and Professor Hugh Scallion (Strathclyde Business School) determined that:
- women expatriate managers will remain a minority until organizations re-examine their human resource management policies and practices, and offer organizational support in the form of mentoring and interpersonal networks.
- the lack of mentoring and networking represents significant obstacles to womens professional development
- these barriers appear to be pervasive across a wide range of sectors throughout Europe.
- current human resource management practices primarily reflect the interests of the dominant group (males) in organizations
- these organizations have not yet succeeded in introducing training and development strategies that effectively meet the needs of women.
- female expatriates are disadvantaged in their careers few organizations have developed distinctive career models for female expatriates.
- gender disparity in organizations and family responsibilities often prevents women employees from reaching senior managerial positions.
- female managers believe that they are often forced to choose between an expatriate career and family
- gender stereotyping is still a major obstacle for female managers to overcome particularly in their home organizations at the early stages of their careers.
- womens progression to senior management is hampered by covert and overt barriers which still exist for women in management.
- Europe-based female managers do want international careers, and many of these managers also want marriage and children.